On a Tuesday evening, we challenged the Home Office’s detention expansion plans at the Haslar public inquiry

Legal Updates | News

Art by Micah Bazant

On Tuesday 17 November 2026, I spoke at the public inquiry into the Home Office’s plans to expand Haslar immigration detention centre in Gosport near Portsmouth.

I was able to give my evidence remotely, saving me what would have been an overnight stay and a 12-hour round trip from Leeds to Gosport Town Hall, where the inquiry was being held.

Haslar itself is even further down the peninsula and not exactly easy to reach by public transport (it’s not often I see a ferry suggested when planning a journey in the UK!).

It’s important to remember that people can be detained at Haslar from anywhere in the UK, far from their families, friends and communities. What would this mean for those trying to visit and support someone they love? People in detention also cannot use phones with unrestricted internet access, phone credit is limited, and video calls require a risk assessment and advance notice.1 The cost of that separation goes far beyond time and money.

Joining via Teams, I am looking into a large, wood-panelled chamber, with officials seated around tables and a public gallery overlooking the room. I can’t hear anyone, but they can hear me so eventually I’m invited to start with a handwritten note presented to the webcam.  

We were given just three minutes to speak, during which I presented a summary of our objections. We also submitted a much more detailed Interested Party statement, drawing on our own work and evidence from 13 other individuals, groups and organisations whose views we are representing at the inquiry.

Our evidence includes first-hand testimony from people who have experienced detention, clinical findings, legal casework and independent research.

Our statement has been endorsed by 52 organisations across the UK, and over 1,000 people have signed our petition, with support continuing to grow. If you haven’t signed yet, please do! There’s also still time for organisations to endorse our statement for the Campsfield inquiry. Read more about who has already endorsed our statement and how you can here. 

What were we allowed to challenge?

The Planning Inspector has repeatedly made clear in writing that the inquiry must focus on planning matters, rather than what he calls the “wider merits” of immigration detention or government policy. In other words, we can challenge whether this particular expansion is justified, but not whether the government’s wider policy of detaining people and increasing removals is justified. In his Third Pre-Inquiry Note, he even warned that speakers could be interrupted if they went beyond these limits.

The Home Office relies on the government’s commitment to increase removals to justify expanding detention. But I pointed out during our submission, a government commitment to expand detention is not, in itself, evidence that these additional places are necessary.  The Home Office also still hasn’t published the numbers it uses to predict how many detention places will be needed. 2 

I was also struck by the Inspector’s list of issues people could raise at the inquiry. He specifically mentions the living conditions of nearby residents, but says nothing about the people who would actually be detained inside Haslar, deprived of their liberty and unable to leave, however harmful the conditions become.

At the same time, he has warned us against raising wider arguments about immigration detention. But how can we properly examine the impact of this development without considering the harm it could cause to the people held inside it? 

Why has the rest of the Haslar inquiry been postponed till 2027? 

Similar to Campsfield, significant planning documents have already been heavily redacted. Without access to key information, it is difficult to challenge the Home Office’s plans or fully understand their potential impact. The Home Office has now asked for even more restrictions on who can see or hear certain evidence as part of the inquiry. 

Because of this, we learned last week that the main hearings planned for 18–20 November have been postponed until 2027. These were the days when the Home Office and others were due to present their detailed evidence and answer questions.

The government is now considering whether to allow the Home Office to keep further evidence secret. The Planning Inspector has postponed the hearings until this is resolved. 

The Home Office has already taken these decisions out of the usual local planning process by using the Crown Development route, meaning local councils no longer decide whether the plans go ahead. With so much evidence withheld and continuing confusion about the process, serious questions remain about how fair and transparent these public inquiries can really be.

What happens next?

We expect the submissions made yesterday to be published on the Crown Development Applications website. We’ll share updates as we learn more about when and how the Haslar inquiry will continue.

Meanwhile, the Campsfield inquiry in Oxfordshire, originally due to begin in October, was also postponed following challenges over withheld evidence. It is now due to begin on 15 December 2026. We’ve also requested more time to speak, given the number of organisations and individuals we’re representing.

Campsfield has a different Planning Inspector, who has taken a different approach and recognised that evidence about the harm detention causes to people is relevant to the inquiry. Last weekend, The Guardian reported on concerns about the proposed Campsfield expansion, including a quote from Right to Remain about our concerns.

Together, these proposals would create around 1,000 additional detention places, increasing the UK’s detention capacity by 40%.

We will continue challenging both expansions, alongside people who have experienced detention and communities organising to end it. We would like to thank everyone who contributed to and endorsed our collective statement – we are stronger together.

You can read our full Interested Party statement for the Haslar inquiry below:

Ally Swadling, Lead Legal Education Officer

  1.  A 2025 inspection of Derwentside Immigration Removal Centre found that just 26 video calls had taken place over six months, despite facilities being available for over 12 hours a day. Inspectors also reported poor phone signal and delays caused by the 24-hour booking requirement, including a woman whose contact with her young child in hospital was affected. ↩︎
  2.  In September, MP Calum Miller,  the MP for the area where Campsfield is located, asked the Home Office to publish these figures for Campsfield and Haslar. The response was that it “does not routinely publish” this information. In its response to objections from No Detention No Haslar, published on 10th November 2026, the Home Office again stated that the extra places remain its “assessed operational requirement”, without providing the numbers to justify their claim. ↩︎


Discussion: